| Fish Species | | |
| | |
| Herring, Blueback | | Chub, Bigeye |
| Shiner, Satinfin | | Bowfin |
| Shad, American | | Sturgeon, Atlantic |
| Dace, Longnose | | Sunfish, Bluespotted |
| Sunfish, Banded | | Fourspine Stickleback |
| Perch, Yellow | | Minnow, Cutlip |
| Lamprey, American Brook | | Bullhead, Yellow |
| Sucker, Northern Hognose | | Hogchoker |
| Madtom, Margined | | Shad, Hickory |
| Fallfish | | Darter, Swamp |
| Madtom, Tadpole | | Minnow, Eastern Silvery |
| Shiner, Swallowtail | | Shiner, Bridle |
| Darter, Piedmont | | Pickerel, Chain |
| Stickleback, Threespine | | Shiner, Common |
| Atlantic Tomcod | | Sleeper, Fat |
| Alewife | | Shiner, Comely |
| Chub, Creek | | Shiner, Golden |
| Killifish, Rainwater | | Darter, Tessellated |
| Bullhead, Brown | | Silverside, Inland |
| Trout, Brook | | Redfin Pickerel |
| Shiner, Spottail | | Perch, White |
| Chubsucker, Creek | | Stickleback, Ninespine |
| Logperch | | |
|
| | | |
| | |
| Sunfish, Blackbanded | | Sunfish, Redbreast |
| Darter, Shield | | Shad, Gizzard |
| Eel, American | | Perch, Pirate |
| Pumpkinseed Sunfish | | Lamprey, Sea |
| Atlantic Needlefish | | Bass, Rock |
| Smelt, Rainbow | | Shiner, Emerald |
| Shiner, Spotfin | | Sculpin, Slimy |
| Mudminnow, Central | | Mudminnow, Eastern |
| Catfish, White | | Bass, Striped |
| Shiner, Ironcolor | | Whitefish, Lake |
| Herring, Lake | | Stonecat |
| Walleye | | Dace, Finescale |
| Dace, Redside | | Minnow, Fathead |
| Minnow, Brassy | | Shiner, Blacknose |
| Bass, Smallmouth | | Dace, Northern Redbelly |
| Dace, Pearl | | Sucker, Longnose |
| Chub, Lake | | Sunfish, Longear |
| Stickleback, Brook | | Whitefish, Round |
| Trout, Lake | | Shiner, Mimic |
| Darter, Greenside | | Trout-perch |
| Minnow, Bluntnose | | Shiner, Blackchin |
| Shiner, Rosyface | | Trout, Brown |
| Northern snakehead | | |
|